open-discussion > brain masking, skull striping
Showing 1-6 of 6 posts
Jan 4, 2018 11:01 PM | Daniel Berge - Hospital del Mar Medical Research Institute (IMIM)
brain masking, skull striping
Dear DTIPrep experts,
I am trying to run brainmasking from the DTIPrep Pipeline modifying the defaults. It turns that braimaksing does not seem to strip skull. Using the "Slicer" flag it seems to run ok according to QCReport, but image QCed still has skull. Using any of the FSL options ends up with image math failure in the QCReport.
Any solution? I've checked the protocol paths and everything seems to be where it should be . Usually I leave the "Brainmask_MaskedImage" field empty but I also have added a subject-specific mask in this field and it does the same.
Thanks in advance.
I am trying to run brainmasking from the DTIPrep Pipeline modifying the defaults. It turns that braimaksing does not seem to strip skull. Using the "Slicer" flag it seems to run ok according to QCReport, but image QCed still has skull. Using any of the FSL options ends up with image math failure in the QCReport.
Any solution? I've checked the protocol paths and everything seems to be where it should be . Usually I leave the "Brainmask_MaskedImage" field empty but I also have added a subject-specific mask in this field and it does the same.
Thanks in advance.
Jan 5, 2018 04:01 PM | Martin Styner
RE: brain masking, skull striping
The Slicer brain masking is not the best (which is likely why
there's still skull in the image,I assume that something was
removed?). For the FSL option, our tool ImageMath is used.
Unfortunately there are other tools that have also an ImageMath
binary (e.g. ANTs or Rview), so you need to make sure that the path
to DTIPrep's ImageMath folder has to be before the paths of the
other tools.
I usually use bet with IDWI
Martin
I usually use bet with IDWI
Martin
Jan 18, 2018 10:01 PM | Daniel Berge - Hospital del Mar Medical Research Institute (IMIM)
RE: brain masking, skull striping
Hi,
After troubleshooting some issues with the paths of the tools, it turns that brainmask does not work because he cannot find subj_IDWI.nrrd. I noticed that when I check "compute the DTI" (usually I uncheck this last step), a subj_IDWI.nrrd file is generated. Does it make sense?
Also, when trying to do visual inspection, it only saves the changes to a subj_QCed_VC.nrrd file if the DTI tensor had previously been computed. Does that make sense also or it is just something related to my computer?
Thanks
After troubleshooting some issues with the paths of the tools, it turns that brainmask does not work because he cannot find subj_IDWI.nrrd. I noticed that when I check "compute the DTI" (usually I uncheck this last step), a subj_IDWI.nrrd file is generated. Does it make sense?
Also, when trying to do visual inspection, it only saves the changes to a subj_QCed_VC.nrrd file if the DTI tensor had previously been computed. Does that make sense also or it is just something related to my computer?
Thanks
Dec 11, 2019 04:12 PM | gpicci - The Pennsylvania State University
RE: brain masking, skull striping
Hi Martin,
I am also having a similar issue. The rest of DTIprep runs smoothly, but I keep getting brains that are not properly skull stripped. I am getting the following error message:
Brain Mask
Brain Mask FSL
/Path/To/ImageMath
ImageMath cannot be started.
Any ideas what issue this may be? Also, you mention that the ImageMath folder has to be before the paths of other tools - what do you mean by this? Does ImageMath need to be a directory above other tools?
Thank you for your help!
Giorgia
Originally posted by Martin Styner:
I am also having a similar issue. The rest of DTIprep runs smoothly, but I keep getting brains that are not properly skull stripped. I am getting the following error message:
Brain Mask
Brain Mask FSL
/Path/To/ImageMath
ImageMath cannot be started.
Any ideas what issue this may be? Also, you mention that the ImageMath folder has to be before the paths of other tools - what do you mean by this? Does ImageMath need to be a directory above other tools?
Thank you for your help!
Giorgia
Originally posted by Martin Styner:
The Slicer brain masking is not the best (which
is likely why there's still skull in the image,I assume that
something was removed?). For the FSL option, our tool ImageMath is
used. Unfortunately there are other tools that have also an
ImageMath binary (e.g. ANTs or Rview), so you need to make sure
that the path to DTIPrep's ImageMath folder has to be before the
paths of the other tools.
I usually use bet with IDWI
Martin
I usually use bet with IDWI
Martin
Mar 4, 2022 03:03 AM | Yingying Wang - University of Nebraska-Lincoln
RE: brain masking, skull striping
same issue with brain masking.
FSL_bet path
shall I set it to my fsl folder: /usr/local/fsl or bet2 folder: /usr/local/fsl/bin/bet2
Any comments?
FSL_bet path
shall I set it to my fsl folder: /usr/local/fsl or bet2 folder: /usr/local/fsl/bin/bet2
Any comments?
Mar 4, 2022 04:03 AM | Martin Styner
RE: brain masking, skull striping
Originally posted by Yingying Wang:
same issue with brain masking.
FSL_bet path
shall I set it to my fsl folder: /usr/local/fsl or bet2 folder: /usr/local/fsl/bin/bet2
Any comments?
to the bet2 binary and thus the second
of your optionsFSL_bet path
shall I set it to my fsl folder: /usr/local/fsl or bet2 folder: /usr/local/fsl/bin/bet2
Any comments?