open-discussion > Where to publish comment on a flawed paper?
May 16, 2012  10:05 PM | Torsten Rohlfing
Where to publish comment on a flawed paper?
Let's say you see a technical paper that is clearly and fundamentally flawed, published in a well-respected journal.

Let's say you obtain the original data from the authors and put together a demonstration that the proposed method isn't working.

Let's say you write a Comment describing your results and send it to said journal.

And let's say the journal editors, while agreeing that you have a valid point, reject your Comment without further consideration because it is "not significant."

Now where else do you send your negative results for publication?

Grateful for any suggestions.

Threaded View

TitleAuthorDate
Where to publish comment on a flawed paper?
Torsten Rohlfing May 16, 2012
Flavia Filimon Jun 25, 2012
Torsten Rohlfing Jun 25, 2012
Torsten Rohlfing May 17, 2012
Christine Zakrzewski Jun 25, 2012
Torsten Rohlfing Jun 25, 2012
juergen haenggi May 17, 2012
Luis Ibanez May 17, 2012
Satrajit Ghosh May 16, 2012
Arnaud Delorme May 17, 2012
Matthew Brett May 16, 2012
Moriah Thomason May 17, 2012
Torsten Rohlfing May 16, 2012
Ged Ridgway May 16, 2012
Torsten Rohlfing Nov 4, 2012
Torsten Rohlfing Nov 4, 2012
Luis Ibanez Nov 4, 2012
Torsten Rohlfing May 16, 2012
Torsten Rohlfing Jun 19, 2012
Luis Ibanez Jun 19, 2012