help
help > RE: Linear vs. polynomial detrending
Dec 3, 2020 10:12 PM | Alfonso Nieto-Castanon - Boston University
RE: Linear vs. polynomial detrending
In general detrending is just one of several denoising procedures
that help compensate for very-slowly-varying trends in the data.
High-pass filtering, and to a lesser degree also aCompCor and even
regression of subject-motion timeseries, which are all part of the
standard denoising procedure in CONN, can also contribute to remove
slowly-varying temporal trends from the BOLD signal. So the general
recommendation is to consider all these factors jointly, and if the
BOLD signal after denoising (e.g. looking in the "GS after
denoising" plot in CONN's denoising tab display, or in the
associated carpet plots there as well) appears to still show the
contribution of very-slowly-varying temporal trends, then consider
applying a more conservative denoising procedure and choose the
factor(s) that seem best matched to the observed residual effects
(e.g. use higher-order polynomial detrending if the residual trends
are well matched by low-order polynomials, use a higher-threshold
in your high-pass filter if stationary low-frequency effects seem
to better match the observed residuals, etc.)
And regarding your question about denoising for task designs, detrending (and all other denoising steps) is always performed separately within each individual session/run, and it applies to the whole timeseries within that run (e.g. it does not include trend-by-condition interactions).
Hope this helps
Alfonso
Originally posted by fmri questions:
And regarding your question about denoising for task designs, detrending (and all other denoising steps) is always performed separately within each individual session/run, and it applies to the whole timeseries within that run (e.g. it does not include trend-by-condition interactions).
Hope this helps
Alfonso
Originally posted by fmri questions:
Dear Dr. Alfonso,
Would you have any recommendations on which form of detrending should be preferred for resting state and task fMRI data? Additionally, for task fMRI data, is the detrending performed on condition specific time series or on the whole time series in general? I understand that the detrending decision could be partially based on how long the time series actually is...my resting state time series is ~7 minutes and the task fMRI time series (overall) is ~8 minutes. Any insight in this matter would be much helpful.
Thank you
Would you have any recommendations on which form of detrending should be preferred for resting state and task fMRI data? Additionally, for task fMRI data, is the detrending performed on condition specific time series or on the whole time series in general? I understand that the detrending decision could be partially based on how long the time series actually is...my resting state time series is ~7 minutes and the task fMRI time series (overall) is ~8 minutes. Any insight in this matter would be much helpful.
Thank you
Threaded View
Title | Author | Date |
---|---|---|
fmri questions | Dec 2, 2020 | |
Alfonso Nieto-Castanon | Dec 3, 2020 | |