help > RE: Movement
Apr 1, 2015  12:04 PM | Fred Uquillas
RE: Movement
Hi Xiaozhen,
The Conn toolbox uses the ART Artifact Detection Toolbox, which computes regressor files for outliers and movement. To my knowledge, the scrubbing you're referring to (i.e., throwing out bad time points altogether), is implemented in a different toolbox with a similar name, that is, the ArtRepair toolbox from Stanford (http://cibsr.stanford.edu/tools/human-br...).
The reason why it is advised to use regression rather than removing outlier time points, is because you want to maintain the temporal resolution of the data. By removing time points, you're altering the length of scans, making some longer than others, for better or worse (though I'm under the impression it is for worse).

It would be nice if you could run both analyses, and tell us what you find. We did something similar: We looked at analysis results using the ART outlier regressors and no despiking, using art regressors and 'despiking', not using outlier regressors and not using despiking, and not using outlier regressors but using despiking. We're still under the process of finishing the comparisons.

All the best,

Fred

Originally posted by Xiaozhen You:
Thank you Fred for pointing me to that thread!
So it's definitely only just regressing these outliers, my question then is statistically the effect same as scrubbing(removing time points when calculating functional connectivity)? since a big spike may still have motion residual effect? I'm wondering is the default CONN option is definitely superior than scrubbing, and whether CONN can provide that real scrubbing option, in case subject moves quite some volumes (especially in pediatric data), for some reason I thought scrubbed shorter time series will be cleaner for functional connectivity analysis..

Thanks!
Xiaozhen

Threaded View

TitleAuthorDate
Kaylah Curtis Jul 23, 2014
Mary Newsome Apr 2, 2015
Alfonso Nieto-Castanon Apr 6, 2015
Alfonso Nieto-Castanon Jul 29, 2014
Xiaozhen You Mar 31, 2015
Fred Uquillas Mar 31, 2015
Xiaozhen You Apr 1, 2015
RE: Movement
Fred Uquillas Apr 1, 2015
Alfonso Nieto-Castanon Apr 2, 2015
Xiaozhen You Apr 2, 2015
Ekaterina Shcheglova Mar 26, 2023
Fred Uquillas Apr 24, 2015
Alfonso Nieto-Castanon Apr 28, 2015
Fred Uquillas May 6, 2015
Arkan A May 6, 2015
Alfonso Nieto-Castanon May 6, 2015
Arkan A May 7, 2015
Alfonso Nieto-Castanon May 8, 2015
Arkan A May 8, 2015
Bradley Taber-Thomas Sep 30, 2014
Alfonso Nieto-Castanon Oct 1, 2014
Bradley Taber-Thomas Oct 1, 2014
Alfonso Nieto-Castanon Nov 19, 2014
Kaylah Curtis Jul 29, 2014
Alfonso Nieto-Castanon Jul 30, 2014
Alexander Drobyshevsky Oct 21, 2014
Alfonso Nieto-Castanon Nov 19, 2014
Kaylah Curtis Jul 30, 2014
Aleksandra Herman Oct 23, 2014