open-discussion
open-discussion > RE: AAAS: Your Paper MUST include Data and Code
Mar 10, 2011 07:03 PM | Matthew Brett
RE: AAAS: Your Paper MUST include Data and Code
Originally posted by Cinly Ooi:
But speed limit is different..... definitely on the exception list!!! ;-P
This forum interface - Jeez.
I think the point is that most of us accept that speeding is not that bad. It used to be the same for drunk driving in the UK, but that has changed.
The current standard way of publishing allows us to wave our hands a little and say 'trust us we did this right'. Most people grew up in labs where this is standard practice. Disputing this practice then seems like unnecessary fussing over details. I think it isn't, and that the current system is badly broken and is letting through many wrong results, but it's very difficult to show that, and so I suspect the instinct of most people is that this issue is not very important.
Originally posted by Torsten Rohlfing:
Sadly,
even large groups can have flexible ethics. Case in point: we all
break the speed limit, don't we?
But speed limit is different..... definitely on the exception list!!! ;-P
This forum interface - Jeez.
I think the point is that most of us accept that speeding is not that bad. It used to be the same for drunk driving in the UK, but that has changed.
The current standard way of publishing allows us to wave our hands a little and say 'trust us we did this right'. Most people grew up in labs where this is standard practice. Disputing this practice then seems like unnecessary fussing over details. I think it isn't, and that the current system is badly broken and is letting through many wrong results, but it's very difficult to show that, and so I suspect the instinct of most people is that this issue is not very important.
Threaded View
| Title | Author | Date |
|---|---|---|
| Luis Ibanez | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| hongtu zhu | Mar 13, 2011 | |
| Luis Ibanez | Mar 13, 2011 | |
| Matthew Brett | Mar 13, 2011 | |
| Isaiah Norton | Mar 13, 2011 | |
| Torsten Rohlfing | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Luis Ibanez | Mar 11, 2011 | |
| Daniel Kimberg | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Cinly Ooi | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Torsten Rohlfing | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Cinly Ooi | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Torsten Rohlfing | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Cinly Ooi | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Torsten Rohlfing | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Cinly Ooi | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Matthew Brett | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Pierre Bellec | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Luis Ibanez | Mar 11, 2011 | |
| Matthew Brett | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Cinly Ooi | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Cinly Ooi | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Torsten Rohlfing | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Daniel Kimberg | Mar 10, 2011 | |
| Cinly Ooi | Mar 10, 2011 | |